Gaines Street Pies Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Gaines Street Pies, a must-visit spot in Tallahassee, FL, where pizza is elevated to an art form. Nestled at 603 W Gaines St, this trendy eatery offers an inviting atmosphere perfect for gatherings or casual late-night bites. The menu boasts a diverse range of choices, from scrumptious appetizers like Garlic Knots and Bacon Wrapped Jalapeno Poppers to hearty salads and unique specialty pies.
- The Smitty Pie: A bold blend of double pepperoni with mushrooms on Sriracha-infused sauce.
- Mo Rockin' Pie: Vegetarian delight with eggplant, feta, and basil pesto.
Vegan and vegetarian options abound, ensuring everyone finds a favorite. With amenities like outdoor seating, delivery, and a full bar, Gaines Street Pies is ideal for families, groups, or anyone craving delicious pizza. Don’t miss their happy hour specials and free Wi-Fi! Dive into a slice of culinary bliss today.
Appetizers
Garlic Knots
6 stone-baked, puffy wonders of garlicky, buttery goodness topped with Romano cheese and served with a side of our homemade marinara. Vegetarian.
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Fresh, hot, and delicious! Made in house and served with our freshly baked pita bread. Vegetarian.
Bacon Wrapped Jalapeno Poppers
Fresh (not frozen) jalapeno poppers stuffed with a savory blend of cream cheese and cheddar, wrapped with bacon, and baked to perfection. Served with homemade ranch for dipping.
Hummus Plate
A generous portion of hummus served with fresh baked pita bread, roasted red peppers, cucumber slices, Kalamata olives, and feta cheese. Vegetarian.
Cheesy Bread
Our 10" garlic-buttered, hand-tossed dough loaded with mozzarella, provolone, cheddar, and Romano cheeses. Served with homemade ranch. Vegetarian.
Caprese Salad
Layers of tomato and fresh mozzarella, topped with basil and balsamic reduction. Vegetarian.
Side Salad
Your choice of house salad with ranch or balsamic vinaigrette or Caesar salad.
Spinach Salad
Spinach, tomatoes, bacon, egg, onions, and feta, served with our signature vinaigrette dressing.
Southern Style Greek Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce, fresh tomatoes, feta cheese, onions, Kalamata olives, and a scoop of our homemade potato salad, served with our sundried tomato Greek dressing. Vegetarian.
GSP House Salad
A bed of romaine topped with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, cucumber, tomato, and mozzarella cheese. Choice of ranch or balsamic vinaigrette dressing. Vegetarian. Add chicken for an additional charge.
Stay Classy Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce, hand-tossed in our homemade Caesar dressing and Pecorino Romano, onion, tomato, and our zesty fresh baked croutons. Add chicken for an additional charge.
Cobb Salad
A bed of romaine lettuce topped with grilled chicken, tomato, cucumber, bacon, egg, gorgonzola, and our homemade ranch dressing.
Arugula Apple Salad
Arugula, thinly sliced green apples, roasted fig, goat cheese crumbles, and candied walnuts. Served with our house vinaigrette dressing. Vegetarian.
Salads
Specialty Pies - The Heroes
The Smitty Pie
Double the pepperoni with mushroom and garlic, served on our Sriracha infused San Marzano pizza sauce. If you don't infuse it, you lose it!
Bacon Blues Pie
Fresh, all natural bacon, Gorgonzola, and house roasted red peppers.
Mo Rockin' Pie
Basil pesto base, eggplant, onions, feta, fresh garlic, basil, and cracked black pepper. Vegetarian.
Bruno Sammartino Pie
Pepperoni, ham, capicola, pepperoncinis, and fresh garlic.
The Mitchka Pie
A savory blend of sausage, baked eggplant, fresh garlic, Romano, and mozzarella.
Pesto Chicken Pie
A basil pesto base topped with fresh tomatoes, onions, and tender slices of chicken breast.
The Saucy Minx Pie
Marinara sauce base, our homemade meatballs, rich dollops of ricotta cheese, seasonal bell peppers, and fresh basil.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Light tomato sauce, smothered with house BBQ sauce, grilled chicken breast, yellow onions, and fresh jalapenos.
The Freaks and Greek Pizza
Olive oil, sun-dried tomato base with artichoke, roasted red peppers, pepperoncini, feta, and Kalamata olives.
The White Album Pie
A rich ricotta base with a blend of Romano and mozzarella cheeses, then topped with fresh garlic and basil, tomatoes, onion, arugula, and a truffle oil spritz. Vegetarian.
Figure Four Pie
An olive oil base with a blend of mozzarella and crumbled goat cheese, topped with roasted fig, capicola, and fresh garlic.
The One with Everything On It Pie
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.
Margherita Mayhem Pie
A light marinara with Pecorino Romano, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and garlic. Our take on this classic pizza gets hit with fresh basil, extra virgin olive oil drizzle, and cracked black pepper. Vegetarian.
The Metal Mike Pie
Our homemade ranch dressing base with bacon, grilled chicken, fresh garlic, green onions, and a hit of Sriracha.
This Is Animal Pie
Topped with Pecorino Romano, mozzarella cheese, and loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon.
The Temptation Pie
Vegan pie with vegan cheese, a garlic and olive oil base, topped with marinated portobello mushrooms, arugula, pineapple, basil, and a balsamic glaze. Vegetarian, vegan.
Honey, I Shrunk the Pigs Pizza
Andouille sausage, cream cheese dollops, honey, and candied jalapenos.
Guy on a Buffalo Chicken Pie
A creamy homemade ranch dressing base topped with grilled chicken breast slices, blue cheese crumbles, Buffalo sauce, and green onions.
Derek Sanders is a Vegetarian Pie
Fresh tomato, mushrooms, black olives, seasonal bell peppers, onion, seasonal bell peppers, fresh spinach, and garlic.
The White Sword Pizza
Those guys. Oil and garlic base with chicken, fresh pineapple, feta and arugula drizzled with balsamic reduction and garnished with fresh basil.
Specialty Pizzas - The Villains
Build Your Own Pizza
Build Your Own Cheese Pizza Slice
Build Your Own Cheese Pizza
Build Your Own Calzone
Stuffed with a rich blend of ricotta and mozzarella cheeses and one topping of your choice.
Chicken Florentine Calzone
Tender sliced chicken breast, ricotta, mozzarella, and our house made spinach artichoke dip.
Calzones
Sandwiches
Chicken Caesar Sub
Tender chicken breast, mozzarella, crisp romaine lettuce, and onion tossed in Romano and our house Caesar dressing.
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Tender sliced chicken breast topped with our homemade marinara and a blend of mozzarella and Parmesan cheeses.
Meatball Parmesan Sub
Our homemade meatballs topped with marinara, mozzarella, and Parmesan.
Mr. Wright's 8" Sausage and Peppers Sub
Savory Italian sausage with a blend of seasonal bell peppers, marinara sauce, mozzarella, and Parmesan.
Newsom's Own Italian Sub
Capicola, ham, pepperoni, arugula, tomato, onion, oregano, oil and vinegar, and a blend of provolone, mozzarella, and Romano.
Eggplant Parmesan Sub
Baked eggplant topped with marinara, mozzarella, and Parmesan. Vegetarian.
BBQ Chicken Wrap
Fresh chicken breast slices and onion topped with a blend of mozzarella and cheddar cheese, and drizzled with BBQ sauce.
The Hero Wrap
Savory sliced chicken breast, fresh spinach leaves, Kalamata olives, onion, a blend of mozzarella and feta cheeses, with our homemade sun-dried tomato dressing.
Bowser's Bluff Wrap
Fresh chicken, homemade spinach and artichoke dip, Sriracha infused ranch, and bacon smothered with mozzarella and goat cheese.
Buffalo Bleu Wrap
Fresh sliced chicken breast, onion, gorgonzola, mozzarella, and provolone, covered in Buffalo sauce and ranch dressing.
Wraps
Desserts
The Cheesecake Calzone
New York style cheesecake and creamy milk chocolate baked into a 10" calzone and dusted with cinnamon.